Well Water Testing: What to Test, When, and What the Results Decide
A private well has no utility behind it and no annual quality report in the mail. You are the water system operator, and the operator’s one non-negotiable instrument is the lab test — most contaminants cannot be tasted, seen or smelled, a point the Minnesota Department of Health makes bluntly in its well-owner guidance (MDH, Hydrogen Sulfide and Sulfur Bacteria in Well Water, accessed 2026-11-20). Use a state-certified laboratory; your county or state health department keeps the list, and certification is the difference between a number you can act on and a number.
The cadence MDH recommends
| Test | How often (per MDH) | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Coliform bacteria | Every year, and any time taste, odor or appearance changes | Indicator that disease-causing organisms may be present |
| Nitrate | Every other year | MDH flags bottle-fed infants under six months as highest-risk above 10 mg/L |
| Arsenic | At least once | MDH reports about 40 percent of Minnesota wells carry arsenic; your state geology will differ, the test will not |
| Lead | At least once | Well and plumbing components can contain lead |
| Manganese | Before a baby drinks the water | MDH’s guidance for infant exposure |
Situational additions, same source: volatile organic chemicals when the well sits near fuel tanks or commercial-industrial areas; the agricultural chemicals used locally when a shallow well sits near cropped fields or in sensitive geology such as fractured limestone; fluoride when children or teenagers drink the water.
The health reasoning behind these recommendations is MDH’s, reported here with attribution — this site’s own health commentary waits for human review by policy.
Route the symptom to the test
| What you notice | Start here | The test that settles it |
|---|---|---|
| Orange or black staining | Orange and brown stains | Iron + manganese, dissolved and total |
| Rotten-egg smell | Rotten-egg smell | Hot-vs-cold faucet check, then hydrogen sulfide + coliform and nitrate |
| White crust, spotted glasses | White scale and spots | Hardness (plus iron if a softener is in play) |
| Blue-green stains | Blue-green stains | pH + first-draw copper |
| Cloudy or milky water | Cloudy water | The five-minute glass test, then turbidity if it is not air |
| Yellow, tea-colored water | Yellow water | Tannins + iron + pH together |
| No symptom at all | This page | The cadence table above — the dangerous contaminants are the silent ones |
That last row is the one that matters most. Staining, smells and spots announce themselves and are mostly aesthetic. The contaminants on MDH’s cadence list — bacteria, nitrate, arsenic, lead — generally announce nothing, which is exactly why the schedule exists.
Reading results without being sold something
Two framing rules keep a lab report honest in your hands.
Know which standards apply to you. EPA’s enforceable Maximum Contaminant Levels bind public water systems — not private wells. EPA’s secondary standards are non-enforceable aesthetic guidelines. Both are still the practical reference points a result is read against; neither is a regulation your well must meet. Every number on this site carries that qualifier because the distinction changes what a result means.
A result is a sizing document, not a verdict. Treatment equipment is matched to a concentration, a form (dissolved versus particulate iron, for instance) and a chemistry (tannin treatment forks on pH). A dealer quoting equipment before seeing your lab report is quoting blind — the report is the thing that makes a recommendation possible at all.