Water Record Residential water, on the record.

Well Pump Won't Shut Off: The Gauge Test Settles It

symptom · published 2026-11-21

The opposite complaint from a short-cycling pump: this one starts and never stops. Both pages are read from the University of Nebraska–Lincoln Extension’s private-well series — this one from Operation and Maintenance for Mechanical Components (G2153, Hygnstrom, Woldt & Skipton; accessed 2026-11-21).

UNL’s two suspects

A continuously running pump, per the source, means either a check valve stuck open (in the pump or the riser pipe) or a break in the water line — between well and building, or inside the building’s plumbing. UNL adds the yard clue directly: a soggy area that isn’t the septic drainfield can mark a buried line break.

The test that sorts them, from the source

Many systems give no outward sign the pump is even running, so UNL’s diagnostic is the one to run first: shut off water to the house and watch the pressure gauge on the tank. If the gauge holds steady, the check valves are working and the lines don’t leak. If the pressure drops, there’s a leak in the line to the house or a failing check valve — either way, a licensed professional’s problem to pinpoint, but now the conversation starts with evidence instead of a guess.

G2153’s troubleshooting section covers the neighbors of this problem, worth knowing before assuming the worst:

Why running-on costs more than it seems

The pressure tank exists so the pump starts and stops less often — UNL’s series is explicit that this prolongs pump life and that starting draws more energy than running. A pump that never shuts off has lost that protection entirely, and every hour adds wear plus the water bill of a possible underground leak. No products are linked on this page; the supply equipment layer arrives only with verified listings, and a stuck check valve or buried break is contractor work regardless.